" /> When Nonprofits Act Like Businesses, Transparency Improves - bambinoides.com | bambinoides.com
miércoles 31 mayo, 2017 07:26
   BLOG, Gobernanza

When Nonprofits Act Like Businesses, Transparency Improves

  • A 12-year study reveals that charities that adopt modern strategies are more likely to share and collaborate. 
  • Over the past decade, nonprofit have placed increasing emphasis on internal performance and financial acumen.
A homeless man reads a paper saying "You are beautiful, you are valuable, you are loved"

by Louise Lee –

For most of the 20th century, nonprofit organizations had a reputation, for better or worse, of being slow to adapt to shifting demands and reluctant to adopt practices typically associated with for-profit corporations. Then, in the 1990s, donors and consultants started urging charities to become more efficient and businesslike.

What were the consequences?

Stanford Graduate School of Business professor Walter W. Powell, along with a team of graduate students, set out to answer that question. Tracking a random sample of 200 nonprofit organizations from the San Francisco Bay Area for over a decade, Powell and colleagues found that organizations that were early adopters of managerial practices have been able to change relatively quickly to become more transparent and collaborative.

Beginning in 2002, the original research team began a three-year process of studying and interviewing the directors of 200 nonprofits representing a wide range of activities, including human services, education, religion, the environment, and the arts.

“In the early part of study, we saw the growing adoption of managerial processes commonly associated with business,” says Powell. Many organizations, for example, had already started using auditors to perform internal financial reviews. Others hired outside consultants to develop and evaluate programs and to assist with strategic planning.

They also employed a form of self-assessment common among businesses: the widely used SWOT analysis, which evaluates an organization’s strengths, weakness, opportunities, and threats. A new emphasis on internal performance and financial acumen led some organizations to change their hiring practices and recruit staff and executive directors holding MBA degrees.

More than a decade later, in 2016, the research team, which includes Christof Brandtner and Aaron Horvath, both graduate students in sociology at Stanford University, revisited the same nonprofits. More than 175 were still active, despite the roller-coaster experience of the Great Recession. Some had left the Bay Area because of the costs, and a few had changed form, becoming for-profits, public agencies, and in one case, a foundation.

Organizations are becoming more porous and open to more people.
Walter W. Powell

This time, the team made use of online surveys and examined tax documents, web pages, and social media profiles. They found that the organizations, especially those that were early adopters of business-oriented practices, had become less insular by actively collaborating with other organizations and soliciting input from constituents through online channels.

These early adopters of management practices devoted more attention to strategic planning, pursuing operational efficiencies, and measuring their progress, says Powell. “This is what, in part, has helped them to reach out to their constituents through the web and share data on the impact of their work.” Younger donors, in particular, are interested in “high-impact philanthropy” and want nonprofits to use metrics from the business realm to measure the impact of their efforts.

Nearly all the nonprofits in the study had become savvier in using websites and social media to interact with clients and the public. A youth choir, for example, uses its website to sell recordings to broaden its audience. An organization that distributes meals to homebound people now allows clients to schedule deliveries online and to have video conferences with staff and volunteers. Formerly shut-in seniors are now able to have more human contact. Many nonprofits use social media to solicit input and “to get members of the community to participate in decision-making,” Powell says.

“Part of what we’re seeing is greater openness and transparency and more engagement in working with constituents,” says Powell. He cites, for instance, a child services organization that now actively asks clients for evaluations and ideas.

Some business practices were even repurposed in ways that are unlikely to ever be used by businesses themselves. A homeless services organization, for instance, uses strategic planning sessions to ask whether it should continue to exist, soliciting input for the homeless about the quality of its services and involving them in organizational changes. Airlines might take note, Powell suggests.

The researchers found that nonprofits are also increasingly inclined to view like-minded organizations as collaborators rather than as competitors, and thus are more willing to work together. Accountability and transparency are enhanced by holding more public meetings and posting tax filings, annual reports, and other documents online.

“Organizations are becoming more porous and open to more people,” Powell says. “And it is precisely those organizations that were focused on building up their internal capacity in 2005 that now orient their activities outward most distinctively.”

 by Louise Lee | Top Image:  Reuters/Brian Snyder | Stanford University | gsb.stanford.edu        

The views expressed are not necessarily those of the publisher or bambinoides.com. Images accompanying posts are either owned by the author of said post or are in the public domain and included by the publisher of the blog bambinoides.com on its initiative.

Leave a comment

You must be Logged in to post comment.

© 2012-2018 - Copyright - bambinoides.com is not liable for the content of external web pages. © Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976.
Creative Commons Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Bambinoides.com está disponible bajo una licencia “Creative Commons” Reconocimiento-No comercial 4.0. Cualquier reconocimiento debe ser a bambinoides.com y a cada autor/publicación en particular.

© 2012-2018 - © Copyright / Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. / Derechos Reservados & CLÁUSULA DE EXENCIÓN DE RESPONSABILIDAD: bambinoides.com (El BLOG), tiene un carácter divulgativo, informativo y de entretenimiento, poniendo a disposición de todos, informaciones, noticias, reportajes, material audio-visivo y gráfico de contenido variado y sugestivo con el único interés de provocar un sano debate entre amigos e interesados. De no ser especificado, los artículos, comentarios y/o introducciones son escritos y propiedad de Antonio-"Bambino" Maldonado-Boschetti (indistintamente con siglas AMB - ◊◊B◊◊). Además, en EL BLOG se evidencian vínculos y se divulga información originaria de numerosas fuentes por lo que ni El BlOG ni Antonio-"Bambino" Maldonado-Boschetti son particular y específicamente responsables del contenido de aquellas.-- USO JUSTO (Fair Use): Descargo de Responsabilidad: bambinoides.com y/o Antonio-"Bambino" Maldonado-Boschetti (AMB/◊◊B◊◊) no es (son) propietario de la mayor parte de los audios-vídeos que forma parte de la Galería de Vídeos de bambinoides.com los cuales pertenecen a numerosos autores, artistas y/o productores. Aviso y reclamo que los derechos de autor bajo la sección 107 del Copyright Act 1976 (USA) permiten el uso y divulgación de este material con “USO JUSTO” para propósitos tales como crítica, comentario, noticias, enseñanza, becas e investigación. El “USO JUSTO” (Fair Use) es un uso lícito y permitido por la Ley de Derechos de Autor, que de lo contrario podría constituir una violación. El uso sin fines de lucro, educativo, noticioso o informativo, o personal inclina la balanza a favor del “uso justo" por parte de bambinoides.com.-- La información y el contenido "multimedia" publicado por EL BLOG son de carácter público, libre y gratuito. Pueden ser reproducidos con la obligatoriedad de citar la fuente: http://www.bambinoides.com y a cada autor en particular. -- Los comentarios y reacciones de los lectores publicados en los "posts" son de la entera responsabilidad de quien los emite; EL BLOG intenta implementar un mecanismo de auto regulación y/o puede decidir no publicar comentarios que constituyan abuso o que lesionen el buen gusto y los derechos de otros. -- Se pueden enviar colaboraciones gratis directamente a bambino@bambinoides.com quien se reserva el derecho de publicación.
All photos accompanying posts are either owned by the author of said post or are in the public domain and included by the blog bambinoides.com on its initiative.

“La historia es en realidad el registro de crímenes, locuras y adversidades de la humanidad” (E. Gibbon)